IPA (2022 – 2023) Multi-Tabling Violations

Dear IPA Players,

The IPA values integrity and fair competition, and we expect participants in every IPA tournament to play with complete honesty. It has been brought to our attention that some players have assumed the identity of other players during IPA matches by multi-tabling. Multi-tabling is not allowed in this tournament, as set out in rule 3.16 of the Format & Rules. Multi-tabling is inherently unfair to other teams. The IPA is designed as a team competition: teams field five players on each match day, and each player contributes to the team’s overall success. Multi-tabling allows a team’s stronger players to accumulate more results for their team and unfairly tilts the playing field in that team’s favor. The IPA is a team competition, not an individual one.

Given the online nature of the tournament, we cannot catch every instance of multi-tabling. Fortunately, we have kept logs of all matches this season, and we were able to track each player’s in-game ID, which is unique to their browser, across all logs. Unfortunately, we found a handful of instances, most of them involving a few teams and individuals.

Below is a list of all players who violated the multi-tabling rule and all players who allowed another individual to take their seat.

NameTeamMatches and Tables
Edward TanBrown logoBrownMatch 2 Table 1
Sang ParkBrown logoBrownMatch 2 Table 4, Match 4 Table 5
Leo McMahonBrown logoBrownMatch 4 Table 4
Olivia BacardiGeorgetown logoGeorgetownMatch 1 Table 2
Charlie SuhGeorgetown logoGeorgetownMatch 1 Table 3
Garrett LarsonIndiana logoIndianaMatch 4 Table 3
Alexander DranoffIndiana logoIndianaMatch 4 Table 4
Ricky WarnickeMichigan logoMichiganMatch 4 Table 1
Nicholas SchulerMichigan logoMichiganMatch 4 Table 2
Joshua BayMichigan logoMichiganMatch 4 Table 3
Justin ChanMichigan logoMichiganMatch 4 Table 4
Hunter DebelakMichigan logoMichiganMatch 4 Table 5
Naail LakhaniMIT logoMITMatch 2 Table 1, Match 4 Table 5
Thomas GuoMIT logoMITMatch 2 Table 3
Nathan ChenMIT logoMITMatch 4 Table 1
Steven LiuNYU logoNYUMatch 4 Table 2
Cong ZhouNYU logoNYUMatch 4 Table 2
Saabiq AliUNSW logoUNSWMatch 1 Table 1
David HuangUNSW logoUNSWMatch 1 Table 2, Match 2 Table 4
Max Cullen FengUNSW logoUNSWMatch 1 Table 5, Match 2 Table 1, Match 3 Table 2, Match 4 Table 2
Leo LukUNSW logoUNSWMatch 2 Table 2, Match 3 Table 5
Kevin FineUNSW logoUNSWMatch 4 Table 1
Isaac BlueUPenn logoUPennMatch 2 Table 1, Match 4 Table 1
Toby HirschUPenn logoUPennMatch 2 Table 2, Match 3 Table 1, Match 4 Table 2
Cody EskandarianUPenn logoUPennMatch 2 Table 2, Match 3 Table 3, Match 4 Table 3
Matthew JusthWesleyan logoWesleyanMatch 2 Table 1
Quinn CalderoneWesleyan logoWesleyanMatch 2 Table 5

As a result, the following penalties apply to those found in violation:

  1. Players will be instantly suspended for the remainder of the tournament
  2. Players may be permanently banned from all IPA tournaments, with an option for an appeal
  3. All points from these players will be removed and will automatically place sixth in their tables with 0 points. Players in the same tables will automatically move up in positions with penalties kept.
  4. If a team can no longer provide enough players to compete in the remainder of the tournament, the team will be removed from play
  5. A red card(s) will be given to the team dependent on the number of offenses. 2 offenses: team may field only four players, 3-4 offenses: team may field only three players, 5+ offenses: team may field only two players going forwards.

Going forward, we will begin randomly verifying player identities early in and midway through games using the platform’s video chat features.

The updated placements after these adjustments are below.

Group A

TeamPointsRed CardsPoints Change Post AdjustmentsPlacement Change Post Adjustments
Vanderbilt logoVanderbilt161↑+14No change
Harvey Mudd College logoHarvey Mudd College129↑+19↑+3
Tulane University logoTulane University118↑+6↑+1
University of Michigan logoUniversity of Michigan953↓-25↓-1
Massachusetts Institute of Technology logoMassachusetts Institute of Technology912↓-30↓-3
Boston University logoBoston University69↑+5No change

Group B

TeamPointsRed CardsPoints Change Post AdjustmentsPlacement Change Post Adjustments
University of Manchester logoUniversity of Manchester137↑+18↑+2
Indiana University logoIndiana University1161↓-1↑+2
Wesleyan University logoWesleyan University1151↓-15↓-1
Brown University logoBrown University1092↓-26↓-3
Northwestern University logoNorthwestern University97↑+6.5No change
Claremont McKenna logoClaremont McKenna87↑+8.5No change

Group C

TeamPointsRed CardsPoints Change Post AdjustmentsPlacement Change Post Adjustments
Pomona logoPomona171↑+2No change
USC logoUSC125.5No changeNo change
Oxford logoOxford120↑+3No change
Cornell logoCornell105↑+2No change
NYU logoNYU931↓-10No change
WUSL logoWashU48.5↑+2No change

Group D

TeamPointsRed CardsPoints Change Post AdjustmentsPlacement Change Post Adjustments
Chicago Booth logoChicago Booth126↑+18↑+1
UCSD logoUC San Diego115↑+12↑+1
UPenn logoUPenn1093↓-72↓-2
Georgia Tech logoGeorgia Tech108↑+6No change
Columbia Law logoColumbia Law107↑+18↑+1
Northeastern logoNortheastern103↑+11↓-1

Group E

TeamPointsRed CardsPoints Change Post AdjustmentsPlacement Change Post Adjustments
Carnegie Mellon logoCarnegie Mellon155.5↑+3No change
Tufts logoTufts138↑+1No change
Yale logoYale133No changeNo change
Miami logoMiami100↑+2No change
Georgetown logoGeorgetown741↓-9No change
Victoria logoVictoria70.5↑+1No change

Group F

TeamPointsRed CardsPoints Change Post AdjustmentsPlacement Change Post Adjustments
Waterloo logoWaterloo166↑+17No change
Emory logoEmory133↑+3No change
Occidental logoOccidental117↑+15↑+1
McGill logoMcGill103↑+8↑+1
Harvard logoHarvard96↑+4↑+1
New South Wales logoNew South Wales473↓-57↓-3

Best,

IPA Team